Draft:Pseudopedia/Revisionism: Difference between revisions

From AlternateWiki
Content deleted Content added
No edit summary
No edit summary
Line 7: Line 7:
Revisionism began to be used as a term in Marxist circles at the end of the 19th century, after Eduard Bernstein, previusly an acquaintance of Engels and Marx, published several books which where seen as revisionist, he also attacked communist revolutionaries Vladimir Lenin and Rosa Luxemburg.
Revisionism began to be used as a term in Marxist circles at the end of the 19th century, after Eduard Bernstein, previusly an acquaintance of Engels and Marx, published several books which where seen as revisionist, he also attacked communist revolutionaries Vladimir Lenin and Rosa Luxemburg.


==Types==
===Types===


===Times of Marx===
==Times of Marx==
While Marx and Engels engaged in two-line struggle against many rivals, such as the Young Hegelians, Bakunin, Feuerbach and Ferdinand Lassalle, these people are not considered revisionists, as they did not claim to uphold Marxist philosophy, dialetics and political economic theories.
While Marx and Engels engaged in two-line struggle against many rivals, such as the Young Hegelians, Bakunin, Feuerbach and Ferdinand Lassalle, these people are not considered revisionists, as they did not claim to uphold Marxist philosophy, dialetics and political economic theories.


Line 25: Line 25:
Dühring's ideas where completely demolished and discredited on Engel's "Anti-Dühring", a book wich analysed and criticised every aspect of his tough. His ideas faded into obscurity and Engel's critique of Dühring became more famous than the men himself.
Dühring's ideas where completely demolished and discredited on Engel's "Anti-Dühring", a book wich analysed and criticised every aspect of his tough. His ideas faded into obscurity and Engel's critique of Dühring became more famous than the men himself.


===Times of Lenin===
==Times of Lenin==


=Kautsky and the Second International=
=Kautsky and the Second International=
Line 53: Line 53:
=Trotsky=
=Trotsky=


===Times of Stalin===
==Times of Stalin==


=Right Opposition=
=Right Opposition=
Line 63: Line 63:
="Market Socialism" and Tito=
="Market Socialism" and Tito=


===Times of Mao===
==Times of Mao==


=Nikita Khruschev=
=Nikita Khruschev=

="Goulash Communism" and "Consumer Socialism"=


=Jim il Sung and "Juche"=
=Jim il Sung and "Juche"=

=Leonid Brejnev=


=Liu Shaoqi=
=Liu Shaoqi=
Line 78: Line 82:


="Prachanda Path"=
="Prachanda Path"=

Since 1996, the Communist Party of Nepal (Maoist) led the People's War against the Kingdom of Nepal. 12 years later, despite controlling 80% of the territory, the Party signed a peace deal with the kingdom, joining the government.

The leader of the struggle, Pushpa Kamal Dahal AKA Comrade Prachanda, instead of forcing the disarmament of the old state, fully integrate the party and the revolutionary army into the Kingdom, beggining what he called "People's Multiparty Democracy", cooperating with liberal and revisionist parties and betraying the revolution. Prachanda's ideas are called "Prachanda Path", mascarading as the guiding tough of the Nepaleve revolution.

Nepal continues to be led by the Communist Party to this Day, and the monarchy being abolished, Nepal continues to be a semi-colonial, semi-feudal country, ruled by an iron fist and silencing any oppostion to the "socialist" government. No program of New Democracy was put in practice and many cadres where abandoned by the party and live in poverty. The Communist Party of Nepal (Maoist) was effectively completely rejected by the International Communist Movement and Prachanda's line was discarded.


=Avakianism and RCP-USA=
=Avakianism and RCP-USA=


=Late "Ka Joma" Sison=
=Late Sison=

Phillipino revolutionary Jose Maria Sison AKA Comrade Ka Joma, was the founder of the Communist Party of the Phillipines (CPP), which currently wages a revolutionary people's war against the old Phillipine State.

The CPP was one of the only parties in Southeast Asia to reject Deng's calls for ending armed struggle, instead engaging in a movement called "The Second Great Rectification", which struggled against capitulationist, idealist, adventurist and revisionist tendencies in the party. Sison was the most important contributor for the applcation of Marxism-Leninism-Mao Tsé Tung tough theory into the Phillipine's particular material reality.

Sison was arrested by the Phillipine government in 1977 and spent 9 years under solitary confinement, he was released in 1986, where he embarked on a self-imposed exile and toured the world raising support for the CPP. He eventually settled in the Netherlands.

Despite his earlier contributions, Sison increasingly feel to revisionist tendencies, which came to full light in 2019, when Tjen Folket, a Maoist organization in Norway, critised Sison for his rightist deviations, which included rejection of the ideas of Chairman Gonzalo, principally his rejection of the universality of people's war. Sison claimed that marxists in imperialist countries should seek "protracted legal struggle" instead of violent armed inssurection. Sison also had many controversial and contradictory positions, such as claiming that Cuba had reached socialism aswell as promoting the capitulation of the CPP armed struggle to the Phillipine Government.

Sison died in 2022.


=Gonzalo's Legacy=
=Gonzalo's Legacy=

Revision as of 00:28, 28 May 2023

Revisionism represents various ideas, principles, and theories that are based on a revision of Marxism. By revision of Marxism, it means the revision of the most basic principle of Marxism, which is not seeking the emancipation of the proletariat.

Revisionism is bourgeoise ideologies which presents itself under a marxist coat of paint.

Origins of the Term

Revisionism began to be used as a term in Marxist circles at the end of the 19th century, after Eduard Bernstein, previusly an acquaintance of Engels and Marx, published several books which where seen as revisionist, he also attacked communist revolutionaries Vladimir Lenin and Rosa Luxemburg.

Types

Times of Marx

While Marx and Engels engaged in two-line struggle against many rivals, such as the Young Hegelians, Bakunin, Feuerbach and Ferdinand Lassalle, these people are not considered revisionists, as they did not claim to uphold Marxist philosophy, dialetics and political economic theories.

Gotha Program

Dühring

Eugen Dühring was a relatively unknown author and economist. After a less than noteworthy critique of Das Kapital and an exchange of letters with Marx, he reappeared in 1865 and began publishing several books. His ideas directly contradicted Marx and Engel's conception of socialism, Dühring was influenced by Positivism. Dühring rejected materialism by believing that human intellect is enough to understand matter and reality, with the laws of nature being intertwined with the laws of human tough, rejecting Kant and his separation of phenomenon and noumenon.

Dühring was a proponet of morality and ethics, being a follower of August Comte and Positivism, Dühring was critised by many on his stance on morality, including Nietzsche.

Dühring was also a rabid anti-semite, being one of the first proponents of the extermination of Jewish people. In his work "The Jewish Question as a question of race, morals and culture" he ploclaims that jews where in a state of perpetual racial antagonism, and advocated for their elimination. Marx responded to Dühring with his on work "On the Jewish Question". Dühring's ideas where completely demolished and discredited on Engel's "Anti-Dühring", a book wich analysed and criticised every aspect of his tough. His ideas faded into obscurity and Engel's critique of Dühring became more famous than the men himself.

Times of Lenin

Kautsky and the Second International

Karl Kautsky was a czech-german journalist, being one of the most prominent figures of the Second International, Kaustky, togheter with Bernstein, was the main figure in the "right wing" of the German Social-Democratic Party (SPD). Since the very start of his career, Kautsky was a proponent of reform and peaceful transition, going as far as publishing a book that included an out of context quote by Engels which implied he was a defender of "legality and non-violence", which Engels repudiated in a private letter.

At the start of the First World War, Kautsky, aswell as much of the Social Democratic parties, broke with the Marxist principle of opposing imperialist war. Kautsky and Bernstein both ploclaimed that the causes of the war where not clear, and as such, the right to "defend the fatherland" was ploclaimed. This was widely denounced by Vladimir Lenin, which broke with the Second International and formed a Third One with explicit anti-imperialist orientation. During the war, much of the right wing of the SPD would backtrack on their claims about the war and instead support France and England.

After the October revolution, Kautsky engaged in rabid attacks against the Bolsheviks and the Russian SFSR, claiming that the dictatorship of the proletariat, defended by Lenin, brought "harm that outweighted the problems of capitalism" and that "the bolshevik dictatorship imposes economic policies that have no rationale on a backward country like Russia." Kautsky also claimed in a letter to Lenin that interwar Weimar Germany was a state more worthy of being called socialist than the Soviet Union.

After 1919, he faded into irrelevancy and obscurity, in private, he critised the Workers uprising against the Nazi government in 1934, claiming:

"we do not in any way regard ourselves as driven to the necessity of answering the destruction of democracy by an armed insurrection."

Kautsky died in 1938 Amsterdam.

Bernstein

Eduard Bernstein, after the death of Engels, wrote several works which where compiled in english as "Evolutionary Socialism". In the book, Bernstein attacked the Marxist conception of the state, and called for peaceful transition to socialism. According to Bernstein, violent revolution only produced reactionary sucesses, such as the counterrevolution in France in 1848. To Bernstein, the flaws of capitalism would correct themselves as it developed, bringing in opportunity to peaceful transition.

Bernstein was also sympathetic to Colonialism. According to Bernstein:

"races who are hostile to or incapable of civilisation cannot claim our sympathy when they revolt against civilisation" "savages [must] be subjugated and made to conform to the rules of higher civilisation".

Bernstein was repudiated first by both Rosa Luxemburg and Vladimir Lenin. Rosa's criticism was fundamental, as himself, aswell as the entirety of the "right wing" of the SPD where expelled. Bernstein later rejoined the party and became a member of the reichstag until 1928.

Trotsky

Times of Stalin

Right Opposition

Left Opposition

Earl Brownder and the CPUSA

"Market Socialism" and Tito

Times of Mao

Nikita Khruschev

"Goulash Communism" and "Consumer Socialism"

Jim il Sung and "Juche"

Leonid Brejnev

Liu Shaoqi

Lin Piao

Deng Xiaoping

Contemporary Times

"Prachanda Path"

Since 1996, the Communist Party of Nepal (Maoist) led the People's War against the Kingdom of Nepal. 12 years later, despite controlling 80% of the territory, the Party signed a peace deal with the kingdom, joining the government.

The leader of the struggle, Pushpa Kamal Dahal AKA Comrade Prachanda, instead of forcing the disarmament of the old state, fully integrate the party and the revolutionary army into the Kingdom, beggining what he called "People's Multiparty Democracy", cooperating with liberal and revisionist parties and betraying the revolution. Prachanda's ideas are called "Prachanda Path", mascarading as the guiding tough of the Nepaleve revolution.

Nepal continues to be led by the Communist Party to this Day, and the monarchy being abolished, Nepal continues to be a semi-colonial, semi-feudal country, ruled by an iron fist and silencing any oppostion to the "socialist" government. No program of New Democracy was put in practice and many cadres where abandoned by the party and live in poverty. The Communist Party of Nepal (Maoist) was effectively completely rejected by the International Communist Movement and Prachanda's line was discarded.

Avakianism and RCP-USA

Late Sison

Phillipino revolutionary Jose Maria Sison AKA Comrade Ka Joma, was the founder of the Communist Party of the Phillipines (CPP), which currently wages a revolutionary people's war against the old Phillipine State.

The CPP was one of the only parties in Southeast Asia to reject Deng's calls for ending armed struggle, instead engaging in a movement called "The Second Great Rectification", which struggled against capitulationist, idealist, adventurist and revisionist tendencies in the party. Sison was the most important contributor for the applcation of Marxism-Leninism-Mao Tsé Tung tough theory into the Phillipine's particular material reality.

Sison was arrested by the Phillipine government in 1977 and spent 9 years under solitary confinement, he was released in 1986, where he embarked on a self-imposed exile and toured the world raising support for the CPP. He eventually settled in the Netherlands.

Despite his earlier contributions, Sison increasingly feel to revisionist tendencies, which came to full light in 2019, when Tjen Folket, a Maoist organization in Norway, critised Sison for his rightist deviations, which included rejection of the ideas of Chairman Gonzalo, principally his rejection of the universality of people's war. Sison claimed that marxists in imperialist countries should seek "protracted legal struggle" instead of violent armed inssurection. Sison also had many controversial and contradictory positions, such as claiming that Cuba had reached socialism aswell as promoting the capitulation of the CPP armed struggle to the Phillipine Government.

Sison died in 2022.

Gonzalo's Legacy